6 months ago
Date: 13 Aug 2022 -

The hills once provided a check on the overreaches of statemaking. Today Bitcoin provides that check.This is an opinion editorial by Captain Sidd a finance writer and explorer of Bitcoin culture.Ive spent most of the last three years living in the mountainous region of Northern Thailand. Nestled in the hills all around the valleys live hill tribes with names like the Akha Hmong and Lahu. Each has their own traditional dress unique language and local foods. To many of us living in the valley cities especially foreigners like myself from farflung places these hill tribes seem left behind by the slow march of civilizational progress. They are often described as our living ancestors. Euphemistically referred to as disadvantaged many live in bamboo huts and lack access to education electricity and many trappings of modern life the rest of us rely on every day. Caption Kids in the hills. Source At a distance these impressions make sense. Once I had a few substantive conversations with these people however my understanding shifted. I recognized my implicit association between civilized and the gleaming cities of modern nationstates might be completely wrong. I witnessed incredible love community and wealth in the hills in amounts I never imagined prior.I wondered what I and many others might be missing about these people their histories societies and cultural practices. What might a new understanding of the hill tribes reflect about modern societyA study of the hill tribes of Southeast Asia titled The Art Of Not Being Governed provided a fresh take. The author James C. Scott posits that the hill tribes were not left behind by the valley states but instead composed of refugees from the negative consequences of statemaking down in the valleys bondage tribute slavery war epidemics and more. The rough terrain in the hills served as a natural impediment to absorption by the state. States have encouraged whenever possible cash monocropping plantationstyle agriculture in place of the more biodiverse forms of cultivation that prevailed earlier. James C. Scott The Art Of Not Being GovernedThe author goes into further detail on how the factors necessary for states to arise necessarily brought negative consequences for that analysis you will need to read the book The Interplay Of Hills And StatesWhen states arose at times in the valleys they provided benefits like security in exchange for drawbacks occasional famine epidemics bondage wars and more. These opposing forces motivated a voluntary movement of people in and out of the hills over the course of history. This movement put a check on the growth and power of states. Caption Individuals families and communities cycled in and out of the hills according to the balance between benefits and drawbacks of the state. Source History as taught in statesponsored classrooms all around the world obscures this ebb and flow between states and hinterlands putting forward a oneway march of civilizational progress. In this history bureaucrats gradually envelope the world in the warm embrace of the nationstate bringing peace and security to all. This teaching fails to highlight that for much of history living within or outside the state or in an intermediate zone was a choice one that might be revised as the circumstances warranted as Scott writes. The ability of people to optout of course varied from time to time across landscapes. According to the authors research the Southeast Asian massif provided fertile ground for opting out of valley states up until the 20th century. The forced assimilation of native free people into states was not confined to Southeast Asia. Source The attempt to fully incorporate hill peoples has been culturally styled as development economic progress literacy and social integration. In practice it has meant something else. The objective has been less to make them productive than to ensure that their economic activity was legible taxable assessable and confiscatable or failing that to replace it with forms of production that were. James C. Scott The Art Of Not Being GovernednbspThe diverse and impermanent farming and cultural practices of many modern hill people looks to us raised in nationstates as a result of lack of access to education and opportunity. However they may represent a way to evade both state capture and state formation Scott writes. This resonates with my albeit very limited experiences with the people of the hills. They are aware of the outside world and sometimes travel to work in the city centers. Yet few leave the hills for good choosing instead to come back to their communities even after learning about the world and immersing themselves in city life.Modern Technology Eliminates The HillsThe ability of the hills to check state power depends on a difficulty in projecting power physically politically and culturally across far distances and rough terrain. The advent of distancecrushing technologies such as durable asphalt roads railways fossil fuels radio television and the internet changed this calculus drastically eliminating the hills as a viable refuge from state power. Roads and vehicles make previously impassable areas a matter of a few hours driving. Source Physically technologies such as roads and vehicles make it easier for state surveyors and tax collectors to reach farflung villages to collect tax on land and production. Culturally technologies such as radio and television allow the state to project messages over the air to distant pockets of people repeating the glory and ideals of the state to anyone who will hear them. Financial tools can also contribute to a type of state control by extending copious credit and encouraging individuals to overextend themselves into agricultural equipment upgraded cars or big homes debt adds up creating new classes of indentured servants liable to banks and the state.Physical flight the bedrock of popular freedom was the principal check on state power. James C. Scott The Art Of Not Being GovernedThese changes together result in an elimination of the hills as a refuge from state power and therefore as a check on it. Moving to remote physical spaces no longer serves as a viable escape from taxation or bondage as state power extends over almost every physical corner of todays Earth and overwhelmingly the areas which support human life. However the hills as a check on state power also relies on states needing bodies to perform work and fight in wars. Modern nationstates have less need for more human beings than those of antiquity something else now plays a major role in state power.The Source Of NationState PowerAncient nationstates derived much of their power from their control of humans and arable land. Therefore the hills as physical refuge provided an escape valve and check on the power of nation states one less farmer and tended piece of land directly impacted the power and influence of the court.Today capital plays a much larger role than humans and arable land in the accumulation and maintenance of state power. One diesel engine can do the work of hundreds of humans or work animals and a drone can strike more targets at further distances than a squad of soldiers. In my interpretation here capital means anything from money to machinery to creativity all of which multiply the effectiveness of humans and land in producing the riches that sustain a state. Machines do the bulk of the work these days. Source Some might object that in many cases the state does not own any of this capital so how does this capital play a role in state power Who owns a piece of capital matters less than the ability of the state to seize or tax that capital in times of need. Many modern states allow their subjects to own their lands and productive capital with the threat of jail time should subjects fail to pay any taxes levied. When state subjects lack mechanisms to effectively resist the state or opt out with their capital intact the state has them over a barrel.So while the hills and physical spaces no longer present a check on state power the land and humans that once escaped to the hills have little to do with the power of modern states. What would present a significant check on modern state power is a hill or hinterland for capital.The Hills For CapitalA check on the power of modern nationstates would need to allow individuals to move their capital out of the reaches of the state just as people once fled to the hills to escape the negative consequences of ancient nationstates. What would a hinterland for capital look likeA hinterland for capital would need to satisfy a few criteriaPortable The form your capital takes must be easy to take with you.Divisible If you intend to live off your capital you need to be able to part with pieces of it at a time to live off.Tax and SeizureResistant The form your capital takes must resist taxation and potentially seizure by states.Value Storing The form your capital takes must store its value over long periods of time it must be reliably scarce yet widely desirable. Without this you risk losing your capital even if the state cannot reach it.Lets make this example a bit more personal and say you have a large sum of savings in your local currency. However you disagree deeply with the government you live under and do not feel as if your voice matters in the halls of your state. Maybe you disagree with funding a police force that wantonly kills people who look like you or you believe wellconnected corporations get the better end of the deal or you simply do not want to keep sweating away in an economic system where prices grow faster than wages.You want to send your capital to the hills opting out of state control. Where do you put your capital to keep it out of the states hands Is cash really king Source Currency is your first option. Currency is highly portable as well as divisible making it easy to travel with and spend down incrementally. However currency suffers from its physicality a motivated state can seize it from you in person or more easily through your bank should you choose to store your savings with one. Even worse currencies the world over are not scarce commodities in any sense central banks have the ability to increase their supply with the stroke of a key and they do this with reckless abandon. Each new unit of currency printed debases the value of the currency you hold. Even if you manage to hide your savings from the state they can debase its value to zero. Preppers may survive the apocalypse but can they resist the state Source Natural resources and foodstuffs seem like a practical option for storing capital. You could stockpile fuels like coal and oil invest in solar panels and stash prepped food in an RV or bunker prepper style. While you may be able to live offgrid in the event of a societal collapse you are hardly opting out of state control. The prepper example here differs little from the traditional run to the hills escape from the oppressive state which modern technology rendered ineffective. Will your portfolio save you from a state coming for your capital Source Real estate financial instruments and capital investments in a business are another option. These each store value fairly well at least historically and can even generate you a positive cash flow should you pick the right investments. However they suffer from a lack of portability divisibility and resistance to tax and seizure. Real estate is a sitting duck registered with state authorities and impossible to move. Financial instruments today almost always live within the databases of third parties liable and loyal to state orders far more than you the investor. Businesses usually have a physical footprint and deep roots in the established legal and financial systems surveyed by states so capital investments there will hardly resist tax and seizure. Free societies for generations treasured it so why shouldnt you Source Gold may look like the obvious candidate for centuries humans have valued this shiny rock and used it in global trade. Where gold shines in portability and value storage it dulls against the tools of the modern state for identification and appropriation of physical goods. You may be able to hide gold on your person but any border guard with half an eye open will surely fleece it.What if you could store your capital in a commodity that moved at the speed of light divided into infinitesimally small quantities with ease stored in your brain and displayed its scarcity with mathematical certainty This would absolutely smash our alternative stores for capital on the dimensions of portability divisibility tax and seizureresistance and ability to store value over time. This would provide a revolutionary check on the growth of state power and a strong refuge for free people and their capital.Discovering The Hills For CapitalNo physical form of capital gives us strong assurances against punitive taxation or state seizure given the power of modern states over the physical domain. The hills for capital will need to be digital. However anyone can copy and paste a digital good and take it for themselves which is not what we desire when storing capital for any amount of time. Digital systems which enforce scarcity like modern bank accounts suffer from a different problem control. Scarcity requires administrators with special permissions to update and edit the system. Participants in that system must trust administrators not to change the rules or affect the scarcity within the system. What we need is a scarce digital good with assurances that no person or state will ever control the system.What digital systems do give us is portability divisibility and the ability to move without connection to our physical bodies and stateregistered identities What systems grant those benefits along with provable scarcityThere is only one digital good we know of that satisfies all the criteria to be the hills for capital Bitcoin. Bitcoin provides benefits unique to a digital commodity instant transfer anywhere in the world deep divisibility incredible privacy and provable scarcity. A memorized seed phrase is out of reach from even the most prying strip search and a wellhandled bitcoin UTXO following best privacy practices bears no relationship to any entities registered with or surveilled by a state. The Bitcoin protocol ensures scarcity giving us simple rules for a finite commodity with strong assurances against any state or ruler coopting the system for their own benefit. On the left we find the dollar hardly scarce. On the right we have Bitcoin with nearperfect predictable scarcity every day until the end of time. Source Bitcoin gives any individual the power to take their capital to the hinterlands out of state control in a time when states have few checks on their power and many tools for surveillance taxation wealth appropriation and war at their fingertips. Providing a hinterland for capital means Bitcoin represents a new check on the excesses of state power in a time when former options for exit are quickly disappearing.Whether you choose to stay within a state or run to the hills Bitcoin is an everpresent check on state power. This is a guest post by Captain Sidd. Opinions expressed are entirely their own and do not necessarily reflect those of BTC Inc or Bitcoin Magazine.

Read in the source

Share this page

馃憫 Collect a daily bonus of 10 Crowns every day for free! Collect the bonus on the personal page of the Crowns
馃敆 Join our referral program and earn 小rowns together! Invite your friends to our friendly community

Crypto Overview Show morenavigate_next

USDT Market Price Change (24H) Market Cap Last 7 Days
39997.79 $ 0 % 760.32 Billion $
3001.33 $ 0 % 360.05 Billion $
1.001 $ 0 % 82.65 Billion $
398.86 $ 0 % 59.29 Billion $
1.004 $ 0 % 50.96 Billion $
101.49 $ 0 % 33.28 Billion $
0.122 $ 0 % 31.52 Billion $
0.7024 $ 0 % 30.96 Billion $
82.96 $ 0 % 29.44 Billion $
0.9455 $ 0 % 29.42 Billion $

Crypto News Show morenavigate_next

Liquidity is strong on alt markets as Bitcoin gives way to Ether after a battle that has raged throughout 2022.

The Securities and Exchange Commission SEC is investigating whether Coinbase allowed Americans to trade unregistered security assets Bloomberg News reported on July 26.The SEC has doubled its investigation of the crypto exchange since it increased the number of listed tokens on its platform.Coinbase now lists over 150 cryptocurrencies after keeping the number of listed tokens to a minimum for year

BTC Markets CEO Caroline Bowler emphasized that the partnership with SelfWealth demonstrated further legitimacy of broadscale crypto adoption.

Central bank digital currencies are the inevitable evolution of todays electronic currencies said the bank in a newly published report.

A crypto island in the South Pacific where fiat is not allowed is making waves Modular homes under construction NFT citizenship applications and a promise of a decentralized future.

Owing to excessive demand Binance has temporarily put on hold the ApeCoin APE lending function. The amount left on the exchange is currently insufficient to satisfy the need for APE by its users. Additionally withdrawals on the Solana SOL network have been suspended a few times since April 25. In the notice published on its 8230

Bitcoin daily exchange net flows have been erratic for the last month to say the least. This is due to the numerous swings between dumping and stacking being done by investors in the space all of which have affected the price of the digital asset in their own way. However the net flows have begun to find a balance and it is unfortunately not a positive one.Outflows Start To DominateThe inflows and

Best Web 3.0 Crypto Coins to Buy in 2022 10 months ago

In 2021 the worldwide crypto market capitalization surpassed 3 trillion with lots of space for further expansion. Web 3.0 emerged as one of the new buzzwords in the crypto industry after the metaverse grabbed the internet by storm. While web 1.0 and web 2.0 aided in the growth of the internet web 3.0 is more adventurous and focused on decentralization by giving users the ability to control their d

A group of experts has predicted that Cardano ADA will close the year at 0.63.The respondents agree that the incoming Vasil hard fork will affect prices but opinions remain split over the depth of the impact.A crosssection of panelists recommends looking at the longterm for any real gains for the cryptocurrency.Finder quizzed a panel of experts regarding Cardanos future and their responses painted

The use and implementation of cryptocurrencies has been increasing sharply over the last few years as crypto cruises into the mainstream. But with the spread of new currencies comes the rise of illicit uses and misuse.nbspCoinJournal analysed a report by Chainalysis to ascertain how widespread crypto crime is which types are most prevalent and which years lost the highest amount of money to crypto

Inverse Finance was targeted with a flash loan hack merely two months after losing 15.6 million in a price oracle tampering assault. The attackers made off with 1.26 million in Tether USDT and Wrapped Bitcoin wBTC. A flash loan is a sort of crypto loan that is usually acquired and returned in a single transaction 8230

Aave is one of the biggest defi protocols with over 8.8 billion locked and over 116505 token holders.Aaves consistent growth has seen its token sit at the top of the performance chart gaining 32.50 in a week and 60 in the last 30 days.The Aave team recently announced the launch of a decentralized collateralbacked stablecoin pegged to the USD GHO.Merlin has also integrated Aave allowing users to ac

Bitcoin was in the red for a second consecutive session as markets continued to digest the latest U.S. retail sales figures. Sales rose by more than expected in October coming in at 1.3 versus expectations of a 1 increase. The result fueled market belief that the U.S Federal Reserve will now pivot its policy. Ethereum dropped below 1200 in todays session.13Bitcoin13Bitcoin BTC fell for a second st

The post Elons Impact on DogecoinDOGE Price Maybe Challenged by the Bears Will the Price Slash Back to 1.3 appeared first on Coinpedia Fintech amp Cryptocurreny News Media Crypto GuideJust sometime before the cryptospace and the Twitterspace were led on fire with the round of Elon Musk acquiring Twitter for 44 billion. This ignited the Dogecoin price rally which spiked more than 36. However quick

The post Crucial April For Solana 8211 SOL Price Might Drop 15 Before Hitting 150 appeared first on Coinpedia Fintech amp Cryptocurreny News Media Crypto GuideThe crypto market has opened the week on a mixedsignal of bearish pull as well as bullish push. Among the altcoins that are still under the control of bulls is Solana SOL.Solana has bounced its previous resistance which had paused its reco